They argued she was living in Spain for 2 years while listing her official residence elsewhere. Shakira denies evading tax.

检察官称，夏奇拉在西班牙生活了2年，但却将官方住处登记在其他地方。而夏奇拉本人否认逃税。

Judge Claiborne's attorney makes the argument that although Claiborne plainly did fail to pay the income tax he owed, he did not willfully evade tax. He made a mistake.

法官克莱本的律师称，虽然克莱本确实没能上缴应交的所得税，但他本意并不愿意逃税。没交上税是他的错。